SIDTM Pune GE PI WAT / GDPI Experience

SIDTM Selection Process Feedback:

Written Ability Test (WAT):

1. Media Freedom:

• Requires candidates to express their views on the freedom of media. Candidates should present well-reasoned arguments.
• Assessors may look for clarity of thought, coherence, and a balanced perspective.

1. Internet Gaming:

• Invites candidates to share insights on internet gaming. Candidates should explore the positive and negative aspects.
• Clarity of expression and the ability to structure thoughts within the word limit are crucial.

Group Discussion:

1. Swachh Bharat Abhiyan:

• Candidates should discuss the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan, considering its impact, challenges, and effectiveness.
• Evaluators may assess the ability to engage in a group discussion, considering various facets of the topic.

1. Effect of AI on HR:

• Involves discussing the implications of Artificial Intelligence on the field of Human Resources.
• Candidates are expected to provide insights into the transformative potential of AI in HR practices.

Personal Interview:

1. Interview 1 (B.Tech in IT with 2 Years Work Experience):

• Questions about the candidate’s background and work profile help assess their professional journey.
• Inquiring about the latest news in the telecom sector tests the candidate’s awareness and knowledge.
• Specific questions about regulatory bodies gauge the candidate’s understanding of industry governance.
• Linking IT with the telecom sector shows the importance of interdisciplinary knowledge.
• General knowledge questions about the RBI governor and the President of India assess the candidate’s awareness.
• The question on why MBA provides an opportunity for the candidate to articulate their career goals.

1. Interview 2 (Fresher):

• Classic introductory questions to get to know the candidate.
• Specific questions about college subjects test the depth of the candidate’s academic understanding.
• Inquiring about Amritsar and hobbies reveals personal interests and background.
• Probing about current news assesses the candidate’s awareness of recent events.
• Encouraging candidates to ask questions signals a two-way interaction.

SIDTM (SITM) MBA Admissions 2022 – Overview and Feedback:

Selection Process:

1. Shortlisting (based on SNAP score):

• Initial screening based on SNAP scores.

1. Writing Ability Test (WAT):

• Duration: 20 minutes
• Candidates choose a topic from 2-3 options.
• Word limit: 500 words.

1. Group Exercise (GE):

• Group discussions with 10-11 candidates in each group.
• Two topics given, candidates choose one.
• One minute to think, 1-2 minutes for individual speaking, followed by a group discussion of 10-15 minutes.

1. Personal Interview:

• Panel of 2-3 interviewers.
• Focus on personality traits, goals, preferences, academics, and experiences.
• Average duration: 10-15 minutes.

WAT Topics:

1. Should yoga be made compulsory in school?
2. Women empowerment is just a slogan.
3. Technology is destroying human relationships.
4. Are Indian cities ready to be a smart city?
5. Technology will create more job opportunities.
6. Indian Political System needs reforms.
7. Do actors/actresses deserve Bharat Ratna?
8. Indian Economy will soon overtake the Chinese Economy.

GE Topics:

1. Night owls v/s early birds.
2. Do social media influencers have an impact on youth?
3. Should social media be banned in workplaces?
4. E-commerce v/s traditional retail shops.
5. What is the need of the hour – more jobs or more entrepreneurs?
6. Is globalization a threat to Indian culture?
7. Movies encourage social evils.
8. Should the wealthy in India be taxed more?

Interview Experiences:

1. Interview 1:

• TCS Work Ex (2 years), SNAP Percentile: 78.
• Questions on role at TCS, time management, hobbies, and current news.

1. Interview 2:

• Experienced candidate.
• Questions on graduation, recent news, and state’s CM.

1. Interview 3:

• B.Tech (Mechanical), Experienced.
• Questions on education gap, low graduation scores, technical knowledge, and opinions on global events.

1. Interview 4:

• B.Com + MA (Economics).
• Questions on achievements, passion for painting, why MBA, and detailed economics and finance-related queries.

Recommendations for Candidates:

• Current Affairs Knowledge:
• Stay updated on current affairs, especially in your field.
• Articulation Skills:
• Practice articulating thoughts clearly and concisely.
• Industry and Technical Knowledge:
• Brush up on industry-related and technical knowledge.
• Goal Clarity:
• Have a clear understanding of your goals and why an MBA is the right path.
• Engagement in Group Discussions:
• Actively engage in group discussions, express opinions thoughtfully.
• Depth in Academic Subjects:
• For experienced candidates, be prepared for questions related to your graduation subjects and work experience.
• Holistic Preparation:
• Cover a range of topics in academics, economics, finance, and general knowledge.

This overview aims to provide insights for prospective candidates and enhance their preparedness for the SIDTM MBA admissions process.

General Recommendations:

• Current Affairs Awareness:
• Candidates should stay updated on current affairs, especially in areas related to their field of study or work.
• Structured Communication:
• The ability to express thoughts clearly within given constraints is crucial, as seen in the WAT.
• Holistic View in GD:
• Group discussion requires a balanced and holistic approach to the given topics.
• Depth of Knowledge:
• Academic and industry-specific knowledge should be thorough, as evident in the interview questions.
• Clarity in Career Goals:
• Candidates should be prepared to articulate their motivations for pursuing an MBA and their long-term career goals.

WAT (Written Ability Test) Feedback:

1. Cricket, Cinema, Culture & Politics – turning points of India (450 words):

• Candidates need to analyze the impact of cricket, cinema, culture, and politics on India’s transformation.
• Requires an in-depth exploration of how these elements influence the country.

1. Image – 2 elephants dead on railway track & locals & police gathered (650 words):

• Candidates are expected to interpret an image depicting a sensitive incident involving elephants.
• Requires a detailed analysis of the situation, addressing local and law enforcement responses.

1. Women empowerment?

• An open-ended topic focusing on women empowerment.
• Candidates should present their views, arguments, and possible solutions.

1. Picture – Bomb Blast in Taj, Bombay:

• Requires candidates to discuss a significant and tragic event.
• Candidates may explore the aftermath, implications, and preventive measures.

1. Artistic freedom, freedom of expression, is censorship justified?

• Candidates are asked to express their opinion on the balance between artistic freedom and the need for censorship.
• A discussion of scenarios where censorship might be justified is expected.

1. Image – UN logo, olive branches, globe with man in suit.

• Candidates are prompted to consider freedom of expression.
• The discussion may involve evaluating the role of censorship and its justification.

1. According to UN studies, Indian masses have more access to cell phones rather than basic sanitation (650 words):

• Requires candidates to analyze a data-driven statement.
• Needs exploration of reasons for the stated situation and proposed solutions.

1. A terrified woman on the floor with a huge man’s shadow towering her (450 words):

• Candidates must interpret an image depicting a potentially distressing scenario.
• Requires a nuanced and thoughtful response.

1. Social media changing marketing standards/methods. How has it helped? (650 words):

• Focuses on the impact of social media on marketing.
• Requires candidates to delve into the changes, advantages, and implications.

1. Image-Black Background, white logo. Apple with Steve Jobs’ face in the bite (450 words):
   • Candidates need to analyze the symbolism in the image.
   • Requires a discussion on the impact of Apple and Steve Jobs on technology.
2. Using TV/Media as a means of adv.
   • Explores the role of TV/Media in advertising.
   • Candidates should discuss the effectiveness and challenges.
3. Name a major depleting resource of the country & steps (600-700 words):
   • Candidates need to identify a depleting resource and propose steps to address the issue.
   • Requires a comprehensive analysis and solution-oriented approach.
4. Image: Road, large pits, man sitting around & fishing (450 words):
   • Candidates are asked to interpret an image depicting environmental concerns.
   • Requires discussion on the implications and potential solutions.
5. Should the right to speak be censored? (600 words):
   • Examines the balance between freedom of speech and the need for censorship.
   • Requires candidates to present arguments for and against censorship.
6. Image: Amul Ad based on Satyam scandal:
   • Candidates need to analyze an Amul advertisement related to the Satyam scandal.
   • Requires discussion on the use of satire in depicting corporate scandals.

Personal Interview Feedback:

1. Excerpts From Interview 1:

• Background, workshop & production in charge.
• Family background.
• Transition from engineering to MBA.

1. Excerpts From Interview 2:

• 60% in SNAP, defense category.
• 2 years of experience in a company (BPCL dealer).
• Difference between sales and marketing, BPCL subsidies.

1. Excerpts from Interview 3:

• 94%iler in CAT, economic honors background.
• Strengths, weaknesses, short and long-term goals.
• Motivation for pursuing an MBA.

1. Excerpts From Interview 4:

• 98.98%iler, 18 years experience in Infosys.
• Why MBA, specialization choice (Engineering or Management).
• Talent – Singing (performance requested).

1. Excerpts From Interview 5:

• 99.52% in CAT, Computer Science Engineering background.
• Importance of academics, role of digital media.
• Justification for pursuing an MBA.

1. Excerpts From Interview 6:

• 98.93%iler in CAT, B.Tech in ECE.
• Hobby – Reading, book impact.
• Transition from engineering to HR.

1. Excerpts From Interview 7:

• 99.09%iler in CAT, B.Tech in Mechanical.
• Specialty choice, thoughts on HR.
• Discussion on training and hobbies.

1. Excerpts From Interview 8:

• 69%iler in SNAP, BDS background.
• Pros & cons of clinical dentistry and hospital administration.
• Job preferences and priorities.

1. Excerpts From Interview 9:

• 85%iler in SNAP, B.Tech (CSE) background.
• Hobby – Drawing, course choice justification.
• Plans if disqualified.

1. Excerpts From Interview 10:
   • 95.8%iler in XAT, B.Tech (CSE), 9 months work experience.
   • Role in college fest, reasons for choosing Symbiosis.
   • Future aspirations and goals.

SITM Selection Process Feedback:

Essay (WAT):

1. Yellow:

• The topic is ambiguous and open to interpretation.
• Candidates may explore psychological, cultural, or emotional aspects related to the color.

1. Terrorism:

• A sensitive topic requiring a balanced and thoughtful approach.
• Candidates might discuss root causes, global perspectives, and potential solutions.

1. Reality Shows:

• An open-ended topic that can be approached from various angles.
• Candidates could discuss the impact of reality shows on society, culture, or individuals.

Group Discussion:

1. Can India be a superpower by 2020?

• A forward-looking topic necessitating analysis of India’s current status and future potential.
• Participants may explore economic, political, and social factors.

1. Is management art or science?

• A classic debate that demands a nuanced understanding.
• Candidates may present arguments supporting management as an art, science, or a combination.

1. Do women make better managers than men?

• A gender-centric topic with social and professional implications.
• Participants should provide well-reasoned arguments and consider multiple perspectives.

Personal Interview:

1. Interview 1:

• Standard questions about self, strengths, and justification.
• Motivation for joining SITM and other calls received.
• Candidates should be prepared to elaborate on their strengths and link them to real-life examples.

1. Interview 2:

• Emphasis on justifying strengths and weaknesses.
• Discussion on a remarkable achievement.
• Thorough scrutiny of engineering projects, emphasizing detailed knowledge.
• Exploration of reasons for leaving the job and pursuing an MBA.

1. Interview 3:

• General questions about self and educational background.
• Focus on long-term goals (next 10 years).
• Specific interest in why the candidate wants to join SITM.

General Recommendations:

• Diversity of Topics:
• The essay topics seem diverse, requiring candidates to demonstrate versatility in their writing.
• Balanced Approach:
• In group discussions, candidates should maintain a balanced and respectful approach, considering diverse viewpoints.
• Thorough Preparation:
• Candidates should thoroughly review their academic projects, work experiences, and achievements as interviews may delve deep into these areas.
• Justification Skills:
• The emphasis on justifying strengths and weaknesses suggests that candidates should be adept at presenting logical and convincing arguments.
• Future Orientation:
• Long-term goals and aspirations are key discussion points. Candidates should articulate their vision for the future with clarity.
• Awareness of Current Affairs:
• Given the potential for discussions on terrorism and India’s superpower status, candidates should stay informed about current affairs and global issues.

SITM Pune Selection Process Feedback:

WAT (Essay, Pictorial):

1. FDI:

• A topic involving economic policies and international business.
• Candidates should analyze the impact of Foreign Direct Investment on the economy.

1. Social Blogging:

• A contemporary topic requiring candidates to explore the influence of social media on personal expression.
• Emphasis on understanding and articulating the role of blogging in the digital age.

Group Discussion:

1. Social Media: Changing Perceptions or Personalities:

• A dynamic and debatable topic related to the impact of social media.
• Candidates should consider both positive and negative aspects, discussing changes in perceptions and individual personalities.

1. Short Films over Commercial Films:

• A creative and subjective topic involving preferences in the film industry.
• Participants may discuss the artistic and commercial aspects of short films compared to mainstream cinema.

Personal Interview:

1. Interview 1: (B.Tech in ECE with Work Experience)

• Questions about the candidate’s academic background, engineering topics, and recent news demonstrate a focus on technical knowledge.
• Discussion about strengths invites candidates to reflect on their personal and professional qualities.
• The panel explores the candidate’s plans and interests, emphasizing a holistic understanding of the individual.

General Recommendations:

• Economic Understanding:
• Given the focus on FDI in the essay, candidates should have a sound understanding of economic concepts and global business trends.
• Diversity in Perspectives:
• Group discussions on topics like social media and films require candidates to present diverse perspectives, considering both sides of the argument.
• Holistic Preparation:
• Personal interviews cover technical aspects, strengths, current affairs, and future plans. Candidates should prepare comprehensively for a well-rounded discussion.
• Application of Engineering Knowledge:
• Candidates with an engineering background may encounter questions related to their field. A revision of engineering concepts can be beneficial.
• Awareness of Recent News:
• Given the inquiry about recent news, candidates should stay updated on current affairs, particularly topics relevant to technology and business.
• Reflecting on Hobbies and Interests:
• The interview explores how candidates plan to pursue hobbies. Applicants should reflect on how these interests align with their academic and career goals.

Overall, the SITM Pune selection process emphasizes a mix of technical understanding, analytical thinking, and awareness of contemporary issues. Candidates should approach each stage with a well-prepared and balanced perspective.

SITM Pune Selection Process Feedback:

Written Ability Test (WAT):

1. All that Glitters is Not Gold:

• A proverbial topic that may require candidates to discuss the essence of appearances and true value.
• Analytical skills and the ability to express thoughts clearly are essential.

1. Should Participation of Children be Banned from Reality TV Shows?

• A contemporary and ethical topic, inviting candidates to reflect on the impact of reality shows on children.
• Requires a balanced discussion considering both positive and negative aspects.

Group Discussion:

1. Beauty Pageants: Good or Bad:

• A debatable topic that involves discussing the merits and demerits of beauty pageants.
• Participants should demonstrate the ability to present logical arguments and consider societal perspectives.

1. Laptops at Home Are an Evil:

• An opinion-based topic that necessitates participants to share their viewpoints.
• The discussion may revolve around the role of technology in daily life and its potential disadvantages.

Personal Interview:

1. Interview 1 (B.Tech in CSE with Work Experience):

• The interview covers a range of topics, including self-introduction, motivations for choosing SITM, and specifics about the candidate’s work experience.
• Technical questions related to the telecom sector showcase the importance of domain-specific knowledge.
• Questions about the latest events demonstrate the need for candidates to stay updated on global affairs.
• Inquiry into future career goals allows candidates to express their aspirations and plans.
• Encouraging candidates to ask questions indicates a two-way communication approach.

General Recommendations:

• Balanced Views in WAT:
• Candidates should present a balanced view on the WAT topics, considering various dimensions of the given statements.
• Active Participation in GD:
• Group discussion requires active participation. Candidates should engage in constructive dialogue, respecting diverse opinions.
• Domain-Specific Knowledge:
• Technical and industry-specific questions in the personal interview highlight the importance of staying well-informed about the chosen field.
• Current Affairs Awareness:
• Staying updated on recent events and global affairs is crucial for addressing questions related to current happenings.
• Logical Argumentation:
• Throughout the process, candidates should focus on logical reasoning and articulate their thoughts coherently.
• Aspirations and Goals:
• Preparing a clear response to questions about future career goals allows candidates to communicate their vision effectively.

SITM Pune’s selection process assesses candidates on their analytical, communication, and domain-specific skills. A comprehensive approach to preparation, encompassing diverse topics, is key to success.